Showing posts with label MicroAdjust. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MicroAdjust. Show all posts

Sunday, March 4, 2012

Super Telephoto Micro Adjustment Using Reikan FoCal


I had early success using FoCal fully-automatic mode to determine the micro-adjustment for my shorter focal length lenses.  So far, I haven't been able to repeat that success with my super telephoto lenses. I did have success using the semi-automatic mode.  I'm still pleased with the product - I'm writing this so that you can learn from my mistakes.

The root cause of my problems was that my rock solid tripod wasn't rock solid. The super telephotos magnify any motion and the motion destroys sharpness.  While you cannot use IS during the test, this problem did demonstrate how dependent I've been on image stabilization.  
    
I made my tests at less than the 50 times the focal length recommended by Canon.  FoCal noticed this and told me to move to the correct distance.  I didn't because I didn't have a place to do the test that was that long.
The motion made it difficult to center my camera on the target.  FoCal shows a highly magnified shot of the target as provided by live view.  The center of the view finder didn't perfectly match the center of live view.  The image provided by FoCal on the monitor was slightly delayed.  Any adjustment I made would bounce around because of my unstable tripod before finally settling down.

The FoCal semi-automatic mode then allowed me to focus, compare small focus changes, and make micro adjustment changes without actually moving the mirror or shutter.  As a result, I was able to correctly adjust my camera and lens combination.

In real life, my tripod doesn't need to be as stable since I will be using IS and shorter shutter speeds.  Still, my photos are only as sharp as allowed by the weakest link in my system so I'm more aware of the need for a stable tripod.  Instead of shooting at ISO 100, I may move up to 320 for higher.  I'll also use mirror lock-up when it is practical.

I've noticed some online complaints from individuals who haven't used FoCal.  They are worried about FoCal requiring the serial number of their cameras.  They imply that their privacy is somewhat compromised.  Privacy isn't the problem - the real problem is piracy.   When I started to research FoCal I found a number of places where the code could be downloaded for free.  The serial number is used as part of the software encryption. Stolen code will not work without a camera with the correct serial number.  If you can afford the cameras and lenses you are testing, the value added by FoCal is definitely worth the purchase price.

Saturday, February 18, 2012

Reikan FoCal - I Recommend It


Micro adjustment is a feature that that was developed a few years ago.  It is supposed to allow the user to fine tune exact focus when their camera is using a specific lens.   It seemed like an exciting feature when the ID Mark III was announced.  However, the 1D Mark III had so many more problems with focus that wasn't consistent that Micro adjustment was a waste of time.

Canon partially addressed the issue with the 1D Mark 1V by crippling the ability to focus on an exact spot.  When you tried to focus on the center, little invisible helper sensors assisted.  This is very frustrating when trying to photograph a bird that is surrounded by nearby branches.

The 5D Mark II also has the feature but once again Canon decided to reserve its finest autofocus for only the top tier cameras.  The future isn't bright, instead of improving the IDX focus, Canon has decided to not even try to focus at f8.

Canon continues to offer micro-focus as a feature.  They have been extremely vague about how it works or the best way to use it.  They have never offered any software to help make the process accurate and repeatable.  For example, you cannot bracket focus using the technique.

No consensus of a best micro adjustment technique has developed over the years.  The recommended distance for testing makes it extremely difficult to tell if you have the best focus or not.  It can take hours to find the correct adjustment for a single lens.  A cottage industry has been spawned to supply micro-adjustment tools - Lens Align has been the most popular.

When I tested the technique, I was not able to produce repeatable results.  I couldn't convince myself that moving from Canon's original settings world be correct.  What if I use +10 and the actual value normally falls at +1?   I could end up making a lens that cost thousands perform like the cheapest lens available.  I decided not to risk it - if focus is critical I may be able to stop down or use live view.

I discovered FoCal this week and paid for a copy.  It is on a PC that is tethered to the camera.  It automates setting the micro adjustment and compares a series of photos to the original setting.  It decides which image is best and adjusts the camera accordingly.

In the last 24 hours, I've tested 13 lenses.  Since zoom lens require more than one test, I've made 21 tests in all.  The reports that FoCal produces have proved to me that while the focus produced isn't totally consistent, overall adjustments can be made that will result in consistently sharper photos.  The results also convinced me that one of my lens needs professional help from Canon.  The reports are stored on my PC so I can compare results with any new tests I make.

I don't have an area long enough to test any lens 400mm and longer.  I cheated and tested the 400mm lenses a little closer.  I'll need to overcome this problem soon because I use the long glass on a regular basis.

The author of the software has a list of future new features that will make this software even more useful.  It isn't on the list but making this an Android App would be wonderful.

The ultimate test will be in the field.  My biggest adjustment is -16.  As of today, the 5D Mark II will use that setting.  I plan to test the setting manually to verify that -16 is actually better than 0 in the real world.